Mattress Protector vs. Mattress Encasement: Summary
First and foremost, let's get to the bottom of this in 60 seconds.
A mattress protector fits like a fitted sheet with a waterproof layer built in, covering the top of the mattress and wrapping down the sides with a stretchy skirt. A mattress encasement surrounds the whole mattress, underside included, and closes with a zipper. Both handle spills and sweat; the encasement adds coverage for the bottom and seams, while the protector is quicker to take on and off.
That's the short version. Which one you need comes down to how you use your bed, so let's look at the details that actually change the decision.
The right pick isn't about which one covers more. It's about how you use your bed.
Mattress Encasement vs. Mattress Protector: Side-by-Side
Most mattress and encasement comparisons stop at coverage. This is not to say that coverage does not matter, but so do the everyday details: how long it takes to strip the bed, how often you'll wash it and what it costs. In the chart below, we cover how mattress encasements and protectors compare at a glance.
| Detail | Fitted Protector | Mattress Encasement |
|---|---|---|
| Coverage | Top and sides | All six sides |
| Closure | Stretch skirt, like a fitted sheet | Zipper that closes around the mattress |
| Underside | Open | Covered |
| On and Off | Quick, like changing a sheet | A few extra minutes to unzip and lift |
| Washing Routine | Can go in with your sheets | Every one to two months, or after a spill |
| Waterproof | Yes, on all of ours | Yes, on ours |
| Bed Bug Concerns | Not built for it | Can help as one part of a plan |
| Our Starting Price | From $59.99 | From $99.99 |
| Best For | Everyday spills, sweat and easy washing | Full coverage, allergies and long-term protection |
At the end of the night, neither a mattress protector or encasement is the "right" answer for everyone. If easy laundry matters the most, for example, the fitted protector wins. If you want nothing left uncovered, the encasement is the better call, and you can compare both in our mattress protectors and zippered mattress protectors collections; this way, you choose the right option for your needs.
Is a Mattress Cover the Same as a Mattress Protector?
Usually, yes, but it depends on who's using the word; that being said, it's often more semantics than anything else. "Mattress cover, as an example," is the catch-all term shoppers use for almost anything that goes over a mattress. So, when people compare a mattress cover vs. a mattress protector, they're often looking at the same type of product under two different names.
The good news is that there is a quick way to sort it out. A fitted "cover" with a stretchy skirt is a mattress protector. A "fully encased mattress protector," a "total encasement cover" or a "zippered cover" is a mattress encasement. If you're shopping for that full-zip kind of thing, our fully encased mattress protector options cover all six sides!
A mattress pad is a third thing entirely, and something that's closer to a topper than a protector. A pad adds a little cushion and comfort, while a protector's job is protection. Our guide to mattress protectors vs. mattress pads breaks down that difference in more detail.
When a Fitted Mattress Protector Is the Right Call
For a lot of sleepers, a fitted mattress protector is all the bed needs. It's the better fit if any of these sound like you:
- You strip the bed every week: A fitted protector comes off with your sheets and goes right into the same load to make things easy.
- You sleep hot: A breathable, moisture-wicking mattress protector helps keep sweat from building up under you. If you wake up damp, our guide on why you wake up drenched walks through what will help you put a stop to it.
- Spills, sweat and wear are your main concerns: Every single fitted mattress protector we make is fully waterproof, so the top of your mattress stays clean and dry; this is great for kids and adults who love a little midnight snack.
What's more, since the protector touches the sheet you sleep on, the fabric matters more than you might think.
At the end of the night, a fitted protector sits right under your sheet, so it shapes how the bed feels every night. Each of our fitted mattress protectors is built a little differently for that reason.
Which Fitted Mattress Protector Fits Your Needs?
All of our fitted protectors are waterproof, machine-washable and fit mattresses up to 18" deep, so you don't have to worry about any height issues. Of course, there are some key differences or else we would not sell them different products. Learn more about what makes each BEDGEAR mattress protector more comfortable below:
- Ver-Tex: uses instant-cooling fabric that feels cool from the first touch, designed for hot sleepers and hot climates.
- Air-X: Has two air cushion layers that let air move all night, plus a Powerband® that grips adjustable bases.
- Dri-Tec: Wicks sweat away with a breathable, moisture-wicking top layer.
- StretchWick: Offers 360° stretch that moves with you and a soft, smooth feel; protector and mattress encasements are available.
- iProtect®: Is ultra-lightweight and breathable, and it's our most affordable option. Can't beat iProtect for mattress protection on a budget.
This is really only scratching the surface on choosing the right mattress protector. Our guide to how a breathable protector extends your mattress life explains why airflow matters for the long haul.
When a Mattress Encasement Is the Better Choice
There's a time and a place for mattress encasements. A mattress encasement takes a little more effort to put on, but it covers the parts of the mattress a protector leaves open and exposed. Whether this matters or not, well, that depends on the situation. It's the better choice in a few situations:
- Allergies or dust mites: Dust mites and allergens collect in and around a mattress, and a zippered encasement can help by putting a barrier around all six sides. Our list of the best mattress protectors for allergies has more on what to look for.
- A new mattress you plan to keep: Encasing a mattress from day one keeps the underside and seams clean for years. Buy our encasement with a BEDGEAR mattress and your mattress warranty extends to 10 years.
- Guest rooms, dorms and kids' rooms: These are the beds nobody checks on, and full coverage means there's less to worry about.
- Bed bug worries: A fitted mattress protector leaves the underside of your mattress open, while a zippered encasement covers the seams and crevices bed bugs like to hide in. Therefore, it can help as one part of a complete plan, and our guide, "Can a Mattress Encasement Help With Bed Bugs?," covers the details and when to get pest control involved.
Building on that last point, if bed bugs are the main reason you're shopping, our mattress encasements for bed bugs collection has sizing for every bed.
Do You Still Need a Fitted Sheet with a Mattress Protector?
Yes! You need a fitted sheet with a protector. This is one of the most common questions people have when they compare a fitted sheet vs. a mattress protector, and the answer is the same for encasements. Neither one is a sheet. A protector or encasement protects the mattress, and the sheet is what you actually sleep on, so the sheet is the layer you'll wash most often.
Here's the order to make your bed in, from the bottom up:
- Mattress
- Encasement, fitted protector, or both (encasement first)
- Fitted sheet
- Flat sheet, blanket or comforter
It's important to note that each layer adds a little height. If your mattress is on the thick side, the good news is that our deep pocket sheets leave room for a tall mattress plus a protector or encasement underneath.
Can You Use a Protector and a Mattress Encasement Together?
You 100% can, and for some beds it's actually the best of both worlds. We cover how using a mattress protector and mattress encasement work together below:
- The mattress encasement stays on full time and covers all six sides.
- A fitted protector goes over it and comes off on wash day with your sheets.
- The encasement only needs a wash every month or two, or after a nasty spill.
Overall, this setup works especially well for allergy-prone sleepers and for kids' beds, where accidents happen and quick cleanup matters the most; after all, kids may be eating, jumping, or even bringing a little bit of nature with them as they climb into bed.
BEDGEAR Mattress Protectors and Encasements
Whichever way you go in the mattress protector and encasement departments, here are the two places we'd start. First and foremost, one of them is our full-coverage encasement, and the other is our everyday fitted mattress protector.

A three-sided invisible zipper, a noiseless waterproof barrier and breathable, moisture-wicking stretch fabric. Fits up to 18" deep, Twin through Cal King, and works with adjustable bases.
Shop the EncasementThe encasement is machine washable (machine wash cold, tumble dry low), and you'll find every size in our zippered mattress protector collection. For lighter, easier-to-wash coverage, our fitted pick is below.

A breathable, moisture-wicking top layer that pulls sweat away, a fully waterproof barrier and an all-way stretch skirt. Fits up to 18" deep.
Shop Dri-TecDo you want to compare every fitted option side-by-side? If so, make sure you browse all of our mattress protectors, then finish the bed with our pillow protectors so everything under your sheets is covered and safe.
Mattress Protector vs. Mattress Encasement: BEDGEAR's Verdict
So, mattress protector vs. mattress encasement: which one do you really need? At BEDGEAR we make both, sure, but we want you to make the best choice. Go ahead and choose a fitted protector if you want everyday spill and sweat protection that's easy to wash with your sheets. On the other hand, go with a zippered mattress encasement if you want all six sides covered for allergies, a new mattress, a guest bed or bed bug peace of mind.
At the end of the night, if you can't decide, use both of them. A mattress encasement underneath and a fitted protector on top gives you full coverage with an easy wash day, which is about as protected as a mattress gets.
Still weighing your options? Our comprehensive bed protector guide covers every single type BEDGEAR makes.
Frequently Asked Questions About Mattress Protectors vs. Encasements
Still have questions about the mattress encasement vs. protector debate? Below we answer the questions we hear the most.

